Alicia Silverstone

(Sophie)

Karl Glusman

(Elliot)

Catherine Curtin

(Peggy)

Britne Oldford

(Sam)

Tammy Blanchard

(Amanda (Sophie's Sister))

Esteban Benito

(Paul)

Sorika Horng

(Jane)

John Wollman

(David)

Paul McCallion

(Morgan (Sophie's Assistant))

Nicole Annunziata

(Amy)

Sergi Martos

(French Waiter)

Monica Rae Summers Gonzalez

(Off-Broadway Bartender)

Kyle Bary

(Dan)

Mike Rob

(Jordan)